Head to head
MacBook Air 15" (M3) vs Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition
Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition leads 6 to 3 on the 9 rankable specs and costs $300 less, which makes it the straightforward pick.
Catalog as of September 1, 2026
Why, in numbers
Swap
Compare a different laptop
MacBook Air 13" (M3)$1,099Dell XPS 13 (2024)$1,299Microsoft Surface Laptop 7 (15")$1,499ASUS ROG Zephyrus G14 (2024)$1,599MacBook Pro 14" (M4)$1,599HP Spectre x360 16 (2024)$1,699Dell XPS 14 (2024)$1,699Lenovo Yoga Pro 9i 16$1,799Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 12$1,849Framework Laptop 16$1,999MacBook Pro 14" (M4 Pro)$1,999Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 13 Aura Edition$1,999Dell XPS 16 (2024)$2,199ASUS ROG Zephyrus G16 (2024)$2,299MacBook Pro 16" (2024)$2,499Razer Blade 16 (2024)$2,999MacBook Pro 16" (M4 Max)$3,499Swap
Compare a different laptop
MacBook Air 13" (M3)$1,099Dell XPS 13 (2024)$1,299Microsoft Surface Laptop 7 (15")$1,499ASUS ROG Zephyrus G14 (2024)$1,599MacBook Pro 14" (M4)$1,599HP Spectre x360 16 (2024)$1,699Dell XPS 14 (2024)$1,699Lenovo Yoga Pro 9i 16$1,799Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 12$1,849Framework Laptop 16$1,999MacBook Pro 14" (M4 Pro)$1,999Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon Gen 13 Aura Edition$1,999Dell XPS 16 (2024)$2,199ASUS ROG Zephyrus G16 (2024)$2,299MacBook Pro 16" (2024)$2,499Razer Blade 16 (2024)$2,999MacBook Pro 16" (M4 Max)$3,499Buying for
Your devices
Straight answer
Overall: 3 to 6
Buy the Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition.
- Leads 6 of 9 rankable overall specs; MacBook Air 15" (M3) takes 3.
- Refresh rate: 120 Hz vs 60 Hz
- Brightness: 600 nits SDR, 900 nits peak HDR vs 500 nits
- It is also $300 cheaper.
Deal-breakers
tick what would make you walk away
- Trips:MacBook Air 15" (M3) · NoClear:Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition · Yes (10-point multi-touch with Pen supp…
- Trips:MacBook Air 15" (M3) · No (soldered)Trips:Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition · No
- Trips:MacBook Air 15" (M3) · No (USB-C display output)Trips:Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition · No (via USB-C)
- Trips:MacBook Air 15" (M3) · macOS SonomaClear:Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition · Windows 11 Home
- Trips:MacBook Air 15" (M3) · 60 HzClear:Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition · 120 Hz
At a glance
The handful of numbers that decide most purchases in this category.
Panel≠
Apple
Liquid Retina IPS LED
Microsoft
PixelSense Flow OLED
Processor≠
Apple
Apple M3 (8-core CPU)
Microsoft
Snapdragon X Elite (12 cores, 45 TOPS NPU)
Memory≠
Apple
16GB unified
Microsoft
16 GB LPDDR5x
Claimed battery life
Apple
Up to 18 hours Apple TV app movie playback
Microsoft
Up to 14 hours local video playback
The 90-Day Owner Regret Check
Documented ergonomic quirks, hardware annoyances, and maintenance realities reported by real owners.
Apple: What to watch for
- Maintenance
Requires ongoing care to maintain peak out-of-box performance.
Microsoft: What to watch for
- Maintenance
Requires ongoing care to maintain peak out-of-box performance.
Display
leads 3-1| Size | 15.3 inches (wins this row: higher) | 13.0 inches |
|---|---|---|
| Panel | Liquid Retina IPS LED | PixelSense Flow OLED |
| Resolution | 2880 × 1864 | 2880 × 1920 (267 ppi) |
| Refresh rate | 60 Hz | 120 Hz (Dynamic refresh) (wins this row: higher) |
| BrightnessNot on the official sheet | 500 nits | 600 nits SDR, 900 nits peak HDR (wins this row: higher) |
| Color | P3 wide color, True Tone | sRGB and DCI-P3 |
| Touchscreen | No | Yes (10-point multi-touch with Pen support) (wins this row: has it) |
Performance
leads 1-0| Processor | Apple M3 (8-core CPU) | Snapdragon X Elite (12 cores, 45 TOPS NPU) |
|---|---|---|
| Graphics | 10-core Apple GPU | Qualcomm Adreno GPU |
| Memory | 16GB unified | 16 GB LPDDR5x |
| RAM upgradable | No (soldered) | No |
| Storage | 512GB SSD | 512 GB Gen4 SSD |
| Storage upgradable | No (soldered) | Yes (removable M.2 2230 SSD door) (wins this row: has it) |
Build & input
leads 2-0| Weight | 3.3 lb (1.51 kg) | 1.97 lb (895 g) tablet only / ~2.6 lb with keyboard (wins this row: lower) |
|---|---|---|
| Thickness | 11.5 mm | 9.3 mm (0.37 inches) (wins this row: lower) |
| Materials | 100% recycled aluminum enclosure | Anodized aluminum with built-in kickstand |
| Keyboard | Magic Keyboard with Touch ID | Detachable Surface Pro Flex Keyboard with Slim Pen storage |
| Trackpad | Force Touch trackpad | Haptic precision touchpad |
| Webcam | 1080p FaceTime HD camera | Quad HD front-facing Studio Camera + 10MP Ultra HD rear camera |
| Speakers | Six-speaker sound system with force-cancelling woofers | 2W stereo speakers with Dolby Atmos |
Ports
leads 1-0| Thunderbolt / USB-C | 2× Thunderbolt / USB 4 ports | 2× USB4 / USB-C ports |
|---|---|---|
| HDMI | No (USB-C display output) | No (via USB-C) |
| SD card | No | No |
| MagSafe | MagSafe 3 | Surface Connect magnetic port |
| Headphone jack | Yes (3.5 mm with high-impedance support) (wins this row: has it) | No |
| Charger | 35W Dual USB-C Port Compact Adapter + MagSafe 3 | 39W Surface Connect / USB-C PD |
Battery
leads 1-0| Claimed battery lifeNot on the official sheet | Up to 18 hours Apple TV app movie playback (wins this row: higher) | Up to 14 hours local video playback |
|---|
Software
2 differences| Operating system | macOS Sonoma | Windows 11 Home (ARM64 Copilot+ PC) |
|---|---|---|
| Repairability | Low (soldered RAM and SSD) | Moderate (user-replaceable SSD and battery) |
Which one should you buy
Pick this one if
MacBook Air 15" (M3)
Fanless 15-inch ultrabook powered by Apple M3 chip, offering silent operation and extreme battery efficiency.
- Completely fanless silent operation
- Slim 11.5mm aluminum design with massive battery life
- Vibrant Liquid Retina display with dual external monitor support
What you give up
- Display limited to 60Hz without ProMotion
- Base model memory and storage are soldered and non-upgradable
Pick this one if
Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition
2-in-1 Copilot+ PC tablet with Snapdragon X Plus/Elite, OLED display option, and detachable Flex keyboard.
- Versatile 2-in-1 tablet/laptop hybrid form factor
- Snapdragon X Elite power efficiency and battery life
- Stunning 120Hz OLED screen option
What you give up
- Keyboard and Slim Pen sold separately
- Arm-on-Windows emulation required for legacy x86 software
Best for each use
Travel
For travel, buy the Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition.
Heavy work
Too close to call on heavy work from the spec sheets. Only refresh rate is rankable here.
Longevity
Too close to call on longevity from the spec sheets. Only storage upgradable is rankable here.
Done deciding?
Open the full standalone spec sheet for either device.
Manufacturer pages: MacBook Air 15" (M3) ↗ · Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition ↗
Common questions
Which is cheaper, the MacBook Air 15" (M3) or the Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition?
Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition costs $300 less at list price.
What is the biggest catch with the MacBook Air 15" (M3) or Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition?
MacBook Air 15" (M3) has this deal-breaker: no touchscreen. No pen or touch input for marking up PDFs or sketching.
Which is better for travel, the MacBook Air 15" (M3) or the Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition?
For travel, buy the Microsoft Surface Pro 11th Edition. Leads 3 of 4 rankable travel specs; MacBook Air 15" (M3) takes 1. Weight: 1.97 lb vs 3.3 lb
What cannot be compared from spec sheets?
Of the 29 specs tracked here, 20 are descriptive and cannot be ranked on numbers alone. Spec sheets also cannot measure subjective factors like build quality, real-world performance, or comfort.